Dark Star - Mascara

Former lover

I’ve used this mascara for years! Unfortunately the last two tubes I purchased were clumpy from the moment I opened them. I’ve never had that problem before. I will be writing the company as well.

No need for a false lash

My absolute favorite mascara. Does have a thicker consistency and formula, but it packs a punch. Lashes will transform after products use.

Love this the best mascara for volume!

It litrally looks like i have fake lashes on when i use this, they get dark, long and volumized. Can’t do my makeup without it.

Not worth it!

I was really excited to try my first Pat McGrath product. However, this mascara was incredibly disappointing. The wand is cumbersome and the product flakes badly. By mid morning I had tons of fallout.

Don’t bother

Smudges under eye at the end of the day. It’s not worth the $$. The wand is also too big. More than two coats and it flakes.

Do not recommend, especially if you have oily skin

I had higher hope for this mascara but by the time I got to work, it was already transferring. By the end of the day I had no mascara on my eyelashes because it was on my eyelids and under eyes

Transfers and clumps immediately. Very disappointing for the price point.

Close to great, but clumps and flakes

Wanted to love this! Pros- love a brush instead of those rubber deelies. Color is nice, definitely lengthens and has a great dark black. Cons: it really clumps. Dissapointingly. Almost need a little rubber deely to seperate! And it flakes off all over my face all day.

Clumps fast and transfers

Not worth it. It clunked the second day. SECOND day! Transfers, clumpy, overpriced. Drug store brands dwarf the performance of this stuff.

WORLD'S GREATEST MASCARA!!

I wear this everyday. This is the greatest mascara I've ever got! Bought it again and again. 100% worst the price!

Transfers

I had high hopes, but was let down with the transfer.

not worth it

I am on the hunt for a volumizing mascara for someone with hooded eyes. Within 2 hours of my applying the mascara, it was smudging onto my upper lid, and at the end of the day, it had flaked and smudged below my eyes, as well.