Flypencil - Longwear Eyeliner

Irritated my eyes, but SO PRETTY!

This color is SO PRETTY! Easy to apply and looks amazing on. Stays on the waterline as well. Unfortunately it irritated my eyes, so I had to return. I'm heartbroken!

Looks great, but too soft for my heavy hands 

The color is perfect and I love how soft it is but it’s too soft for my heavy handed self. I will definitely be going back to the liquid liner but if you could control your hands and you love the way, Cole looks on your eyes which I do love that look, this is definitely for you.

Shockingly bad quality. Yucky and scratchy

Yucky 😒 Texture is scratchy and nasty. Its made my eyes water it"s so rough! I've bought 3 diff colors (to see if they're all rough and gross - they are!). I regret wasting my money and I'm shocked these have any good reviews tbh.

Color Pop Non Lasting

Loved the color but it is not long lasting- the color started to fade within 5 hours.

Disappointed

I couldn’t even get it to work. It was so dry. I was super disappointed. 

Dries up & becomes like crumbly chaulk in no time

Out of the box on Day 1, this product is amazing. It only goes downhill after that. It typically takes me longer than a few months to use up an entire eye liner. This has so very little product inside of it, I was done in a few weeks. And don't think you can twist it out to see how much you have left because then you can't get it back inside the pencil holder. It's soft like butter when you start using it. The pencil quickly dries up, doesn't glide over your skin and leaves crumbs as you try to apply. You'll be lucky if the eyeliner doesn't break out of the container and just fall out in chunks. ANY brand is better than this stuff!

Love the Color, but Super Fragile + Prone to Break

Love the color and how easily it is to apply, but it’s soo fragile. I’ve bought this liner in several colors but each time, 25% or more has broken off (and it’s not like I’m rolling out the whole stick so it’s fragile, it just breaks off with normal use). I’ve bought it several times because I love the color and can’t find one exactly like it, but sadly don’t think I’ll be buying another one because each time, it leaves me frustrated and spending more money to replace.

my holy grail! will repurchase over and over!

This liner DOES NOT BUDGE!! I have oily hooded lids and everything transfers, but not this! This is my new holy grail. I never thought I would find something that actually doesn't transfer -- even after a 12-hr shift. I also have the green and it's also great! FYI If you want to smudge it, you need to work fast before it sets down but it still smudges, though this is not a formula I use if I want a very smudged look. It sets pretty quickly.)

86 cherry punk

After using this product, it barely shows up on your eye line. It doesn’t glide on easily and I wouldn’t recommend this color. Love the black and grey shimmer.

Waste of money

If I could go for no stars, I would. Utterly disappointing. First use and the product literally slipped completely out of the pencil as soon as I turned it upside down to use on my eye lid.

Terrible

I found it really annoying to use and it would pull on my eyelids whenever I tried applying it. It would not twist down so if you twisted too much, it would break after putting the lid back on. Will not be repurchasing.

This wouldn’t turn after a single use. Do not recommend.