Double Take Eyeliner

Liner of the month

Love the brush applicator— wish it was more pigmented. The crayon side could be more smooth. It feels like you really have to press to get any pigment and then it’s just messy and also it’s my eye ball.

It’s a no from me

I personally do not like this eyeliner at all. Within two hours it was flaking off and looked awful!

It’s very longing lasting and waterproof.

Was in my history class today, was crying because we were hearing the nanjing massacre survivor’s stories. This eyeliner didn’t smug or wipe off. I would 100% buy this again, it’s also great if you’re just starting to do eyeliner and you don’t know if pencil or liquid eyeliner is your cup of tea. Great eyeliner.

After using KVD tattoo/ink liner for 8 years, I decided to switch it up and this eyeliner has been an absolute godsend. I will say I mainly use it for the liquid side. Not a fan of the pencil side but that’s not relevant to me anyway. I’m an oily skin girly and this one lasts me a good 7 ish hours before smudging. Of course powder and set as you will, but I will be making this my main eyeliner from here on.

Not a good liner

The pencil is really short and broke after a couple of uses. The liquid liner creates a thick line but is a bit watery, so it didn't create a sharp line and tended to smudge.

Great but I only like the liquid side!

I hate that this thing has both on one pencil. I find the none liquid side to be a complete waste! It doesn’t work well on my eye and its hard to use! It’s too dry. It’s a complete ripoff to have it be there because the liquid runs out fast. Can’t they just make a liquid without this other side?? So frustrating! I only like the liquid side!

The pencil side is terrible!

I don't know if they recently changed the formula or my purchase was from a bad batch, but the pencil side of this did not glide on nicely. it was very dry and crumbly. I've only used it about 5 times, and now the pencil got stuck in the lid and squished all over, so it's now completely unusable. The liquid side is amazing, but I definitely won't be repurchased this duo again. It's a shame because this was one of my favorite products from Tarte. I gave it 2 stars simply for the fact that the liquid liner is great.

Never loved an eyeliner so much!!

This is the best eyeliner I've ever tried, and I have tried plenty. It glides on so smoothly and stays all night without smudges. It's pricey but worth every penny.

Pass on this

Am not loving this product. The liner does not glide and it’s not a lovely shade of brown. Feels like a drugstore version which was disappointing because I was quite happy with their liner/ shadow pencil

Terrible

The gel side was just bad from the beginning. super dry. The pigment wouldn't stick and the "gel" would just crumble.. The liquid side was promising at first. But it dried out so quickly... Not worth the price at all!

Survived tv watching tears.

Cried watching a tv show, eyeliner still looks decent. Love that it’s a liquid and gel in one. Great for traveling.

Meh

Meh, not very impressed. The marker tip deformed after a while, and the pencil side tends to come loose too easily. The color payoff is great, and it’s definitely convenient to have both options, but it’s not something I’d repurchase.